14 Comments
User's avatar
TIM LYNCH's avatar

This is superb. Not a word wasted.

Expand full comment
EllisGee's avatar

There is also a fatal conceit in the Arab world: Everything happens because Allah wills it. There is no sense of personal responsibility in Arabic. While an English speaker would say, “I broke the glass,” an Arabic speaker would say’”Allah willed the glass to break.” It will be their undoing.

Expand full comment
Not so young anymore.'s avatar

Iran is not Arabic

Expand full comment
Fereydoun's avatar

A brilliant write up. Thanks very much.

The 1979 Islamic revolution and ousting of Shah was engineered by bazaar, clerics and the people. This one also started from the bazaar but without clerical support. 3.4 million small and medium businesses are hurt by couple of major financial-military giants who don’t let anyone else to take a share of the economy. As such the structure has changed.

You made important analysis in yours.

Thanks very much.

Expand full comment
CarlW's avatar

Can people now see how wrongheaded Obama's "nuclear deal" and Biden's attempt to revive it were? Will the policy makers behind these efforts come clean so their unwitting followers can perhaps gain a more accurate picture of how the world works?

Expand full comment
Not so young anymore.'s avatar

The deals enriched Iran.

Expand full comment
Alex's avatar

Pure awesomeness. Iran deserves better.

Expand full comment
Mark Trouble's avatar

The main point is he is old. Not that Iran is the worse-test evar and Israel and America are the bestest evar.

But keeping living vicariously through international events hoping your tribe achieves some safety while completely surrounded by dar al Islam. And your partners in the West who are increasingly convinced of your abuse, apathy and impotence.

Expand full comment
Frederick Roth's avatar

Hopefully this time it will finally happen.

Sic Semper Tyrannis.

Expand full comment
Les Vitailles's avatar

Most of Iran's water problems are man-made as IRGC-linked entities built dams and irrigation infrastructure that consumed more water than could be replenished, never a good strategy for the long-term. The long-term is here.

https://www.meforum.org/mef-observer/the-water-crisis-highlights-the-day-after-problem-for-regime-change

Expand full comment
Bill Darrow's avatar

Excellent intelligence report, identifying deep fault lines and political oversights/failures. Let’s hope you are correct that the cumulative problems, this time, will result in “regime change.” It would be interesting to hear you address next steps in the event the regime does collapse. What chances of a successful replacement? How best to cultivate a promising new government?

Expand full comment
Rick S's avatar

Pretty remarkable and exceptionally comprehensive..

Expand full comment
forumposter123@protonmail.com's avatar

Didn’t know about the water.

Oct 7th is going to end in the destruction of the Iranian regime.

Expand full comment
Len Layton's avatar

The main weakness of the Iranian regime is the stupid hats they all wear.

What is it with the hats ?

Expand full comment